Mix, Match & Save

Build Your
Own Box

Our flavors, your size, your box. Build the perfect mix and make it exactly what you want.

2, 4, 8, or 12 jars
Mix any flavors
Save up to 25%
Free ship over $70

Jars selected: 0 / 4

Select 4 more

Unicorn Crave'n Cup
0

Unicorn Crave'n Cup

Tie-Dye Vanilla Cake, Cake Batter Buttercream, Loaded With Neon Confetti Sprinkles. Handcrafted by the award-winning team behind The...

    Contains: wheat, dairy, eggs

    Cookie Butter Delight Crave'n Cup
    0

    Cookie Butter Delight Crave'n Cup

    Vanilla Cake, Cookie Butter Filling, Cookie Butter Buttercream, Cookie Butter Crumbs. Handcrafted by the award-winning team behind The...

      Contains: wheat, dairy, eggs

      Cookies 'n Cream Crave'n Cup
      0

      Cookies 'n Cream Crave'n Cup

      Marble Cake, Cookies 'n Cream Buttercream, Oreo® Pieces. Handcrafted by the award-winning team behind The Cake Girl.

        Contains: wheat, dairy, eggs

        Lady in Red Crave'n Cup
        0

        Lady in Red Crave'n Cup

        Red Velvet Cake, Cream Cheese Icing, Red Velvet Cake Crumbs. Handcrafted by the award-winning team behind The Cake...

          Contains: wheat, dairy, eggs

          What People Are Saying

          Worth Every Craving.

          4.9 average across all flavors

          "Absolutely the best dessert I've had shipped"

          I ordered the Variety Pack for my sister's birthday and the whole family was obsessed. They arrived perfectly cold and every layer tasted exactly like a real bakery cake.

          Sarah M. Verified buyer
          Variety Pack · 8-pack

          ""Best corporate gift we've ever sent""

          Sent Crave'n Cups to our entire team of 24. Every single person messaged me about it. The per-recipient note feature made it feel so personal. Will absolutely use again for every occasion.

          Jessica T. Verified buyer
          Purchased: Variety Pack · 12-pack ×2

          ""Subscribed on my second order and never looked back""

          Lady in Red is probably the single best dessert I've eaten in my life. I'm not exaggerating. The cream-cheese layer is genuinely unreal. Subscribing saved me 20% and I've skipped zero orders.

          Marco D. Verified buyer
          Purchased: Lady in Red · Subscribe 8-pack

          "Absolutely the best dessert I've had shipped"

          I ordered the Variety Pack for my sister's birthday and the whole family was obsessed. They arrived perfectly cold and every layer tasted exactly like a real bakery cake.

          Sarah M. Verified buyer
          Variety Pack · 8-pack
          Common Questions

          Have A Question?

          Everything you might be wondering before your first jar.
          Do you offer custom cakes in Tampa, FL?

          Yes! We create one-of-a-kind custom cakes in Tampa for birthdays, weddings, anniversaries, baby showers, corporate events, and more.

          Can I order mini cupcakes for my event?

          Absolutely. Our famous mini cupcakes are perfect for weddings, parties, and corporate events. With over 85 flavors in rotation, there’s something for everyone.

          Where are you located?

          The Cake Girl is located at 14851 N Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33618. We proudly serve the greater Tampa Bay area including Clearwater, St. Pete, and Sarasota.

          How far in advance should I place my order?

          We recommend placing custom cake orders at least 2-3 weeks in advance. For weddings and large events, 4-6 weeks is best to secure your date.

          See all FAQs →

          Still Need Help?

          Still wondering something? Send us a note and we'll help you out.

          Email US